TALK BACK: Now you can add YOUR comments about this article.

    print version     email

Wednesday, November 11, 2009

Another Veterans Day, another war


By PAT MURPHY
Express Staff Writer

The optimism of President Woodrow Wilson that World War I would be the war to end all wars surely, in retrospect, was one of history's most naïve hopes.

Including The Great War of 1914-18, which saw 15 million on all sides killed on the battlefield, including 53,513 American doughboys, the United States has been involved in six wars—World War II, Korea, Vietnam, Persian Gulf War I and Iraq-Afghanistan—in the 20th and 21st centuries.

In total, 30.5 million Americans have served in uniform in that time. Combat deaths have totaled 431,852.

And, on the average of every 14 years, U.S. forces have been sent into battle somewhere in the world.

Here we are on another Veterans Day, celebrating and honoring the men and women who've donned the nation's uniform to serve in peace and war, with American troops in shooting wars in two countries and history predicting yet more armed conflicts to come down the road.

Today's U.S. military is a world apart from the World War I four-stacker destroyer on which my father served as a gunner's mate, and vastly different even from the infantry in which I served during the Korean War.

Laser-guided "smart" bombs delivered by pilotless drones. Lighter, faster-firing infantry weapons. Impregnable tanks. Satellite communications. Individual radios for ground troops. Better training. More comfortable living quarters. More nutritious food. Better pay. Family-friendly military bases. Global e-mail service for combat troops.

U.S. forces also have other "weapons" that their battlefield foes lack—unit morale and virtually unified support of the American people, plus equipment considered the best in the world.

Yet, sending Americans into battle so periodically is inane. More lives are lost, more families are left in despair and more of the national treasure is diverted from constructive needs into military equipment and operations.

A new phrase also has entered the U.S. political vocabulary that adds to the pointlessness of war—"wars of choice" rather than wars of necessity.

If war is a matter of choice, then American politicians should more vigorously choose not to go to war, rather than following their inevitable impulse to flex their muscles and manliness and send more young people into harm's way.

Cool political heads should give the same credence to diplomacy as much as America's military might when an incendiary international crisis becomes a temptation to rush U.S. military units into battle.

"Victory" shouldn't always mean throwing more lives and billions of dollars into the pyre of war.

Britain's Winston Churchill had it right when he said, "To jaw-jaw is always better than war-war."


    print version     email


There are 14 comments


The comments below are from the readers of mtexpress.com and in no way represent the views of Express Publishing Inc.
My View
11/13/09 - 09:44

Step Right - Step Left - Step Right - Step Left - Step Right - Step Left - Step Right - Step Left - Guess you're all in the same place...

My View
11/11/09 - 12:03

These apostate White Protestant and Baptists, ecumenically and politically linked with the Pope’s White Roman Catholics, endured Rome’s Great Depression caused by key short-seller of stock, Knight of Malta Joe Kennedy; fought the Pope’s Second Thirty Years’ War (1914-1945) that destroyed apostate Protestant Lutheran Prussia and the anti-Jesuit Japanese people; fought the Pope’s Cold War that built Communist Red China and the USSR; fought the Pope’s no-win Korean War overseen by Cardinal Spellman; paid the Pope’s socialist-communist income/excise/privilege tax to finance merely the interest on the nation’s national debt; sent their sons to fight the Pope’s no-win Vietnam War; refused to demand the truth about the Pope’s assassination of President Kennedy; and now broken with no savings and no retirement—thanks to the Pope’s Wall Street Bankers “bailout,” have been put out to sea to fend for themselves—thanks to the Pope’s Health Care Bill soon to be passed by the Senate, and utterly dazed—while addicted to the Pope’s pharmaceuticals, as to how their complete destruction came about. This “Greatest of Generations” is composed of the greatest losers in American history.

Reply to My View
mpc
11/11/09 - 15:24

Wow. I can't tell who you hate more, whites or catholics. Substitute black and jew or black and muslim and this diatribe would have pulled instantly. Answer this how can someone be ecumenically linked to a religion, if they have abandoned their faith? By greed or politics berhaps. Boy these popes sure are busy, aren't they? Oh, by the way, that stuff that Dan Brown writes, is fiction!

Try this theory on for size. John Kennedy was put into office by mob funding. When he started after the mob, he was killed. Is that too simple for your conspiratorial mind? How about this one? An uneducated electorate found they could get stuff from the government if they voted for bad people. As more people got on the dole the polititions became more corrupt and everyone just ran out of money to steal. If our electorate were civic minded, instead of being stupid and greedy, they would vote for decent representatives and America would not have squandered it's wealth on lost causes. I don't believe in Utopia, and I certainly did not think Utopia was high unemployment, a collapsed dollar, two wars overseas, and an economy in the tank. All you utopians who have been living off the largess of the "rich" are going to have to find a way to get by. You have just inherited the earth.

Reply to My View
My View
11/11/09 - 15:49

MPC, for and apparent republican conservative defender you seem to have forgotten, or have never been properly instructed in correct Biblical prophecy, nor actual world or American abuses by the papacy history.. Funny how all this fighting for freedom and forced democracy has brought us to the fascism you yourself whine and cry about consistently.. This entire last five centuries alone can be specifically tied into today's current events and final global one world governance which will allow a single elite group to actually think they own this planet and all of humanity, who wants this ? and has wanted this for seven or more centuries ? If you think America is really free - try speeding sometime,try to smoke cannabis because you don't like poisonous alcoholic beverages, try to sleep on public property because you have lost everything due to crooked bankers and governments who protect them and not you, try to not pay your property taxes on your home you own free and clear, and watch them come remove you from it and take it away from you, try and keep all your income you created with your two hands because you know the truth that it is not constitutional for them to force you to voluntarily comply, and not one law says you must comply, try doing anything on public lands or even your own private lands without a permit, You think free speech is real, and we have open markets in America, ask your self then why does the author of this reply own several American written books, not allowed to be published or brought forth into the market place for you to have the opportunity to choose them for your self, soon in free America we'll have GPS meters on our cars, meters on our private wells, meters in our wrists via RFID chips with all our health and banking info on it, United Nations Environmental Nazi police home invasions to inspect your carbon footprints, all based on the hugest hoax (global Warming) orchestrated in history, $15,000 health package minimum coverage, try not complying with this nonsense, five years in prison, $250,000 fine, try speaking out about it, posting the truth all over the web, the SILENCE ROARS. The yoke is there, whether folks care to see it or not, take the blue pill, cowards can live another day if their lucky.. YAA, thanks a bunch Vets...For fighting for a pile of lies, What a fitting end for CFR-controlled Tom Brokaw’s “The Greatest Generation.”

Reply to My View
hooooboyyyy
11/11/09 - 16:20

god, ur a freak. im sure u think the moon landing was a hoax.

Reply to My View
God yur a freaK
11/11/09 - 19:44

He is a freak, pretty bad when freaks are right.

Buried on page 18, paragraph 38, of the negotiating text of the Copenhagen Protocol to the Climate Change Treaty, are these words:

"The scheme for the new institutional arrangement under the Convention will be based on three basic pillars: government; facilitative mechanism; and financial mechanism..."

The text goes on to define the Conference of the Parties (COP) as the government to oversee the "facilitative and financial mechanisms." The facilitative mechanism includes five agencies, one of which specializes in international monitoring, reporting, and compliance. The financial mechanism also includes five agencies, one of which specializes in compensation for losses and damages caused by excessive emissions from developed nations. If this language is adopted in Copenhagen, and the treaty is ratified by the Senate, every American who uses energy will be subject to a United Nation's agency empowered to monitor energy use, collect taxes, fines, and other revenues for redistribution to other nations.

Reply to My View
GMo
11/11/09 - 20:15

You go get em Greg

Reply to My View
mpc
11/11/09 - 23:43

My View:
This is a reply to your reply.

The conservative position has always been to deal freely with all people yet have no military entanglements. That is the Libertarian view, today. That is not what has been happening. We all had a chance to be great and yet we have sacrificed it all for a promise of a chicken in every pot.

How many conservative republicans do you know?

Reply to My View
My View
11/13/09 - 09:38

Not one, their communists as are their counter parts.. Force fed chicken sounds sooooo good.. The same thinkers invented the third politico version as well, no thanks, I'm a political party atheist.. I don't believe in the two headed one political party dogma for fools..

bob
11/11/09 - 11:08

So, Pat as Obama gets ready to deploy 30-40,000 Americans to Afganistan you seem unable or unwilling to make a stand for or against your beloved Obama. By the way Pat, if the other Muslim down in Ft. Hood had used a bomb would it have been terrorism? Man up Pat. Obama is lost!!

mpc
11/11/09 - 10:53

Dear Pat:
Once again you seem nearly libertarian in your views. I am wondering, had you not been born at a time when socialist propaganda was so prevalent you may have become a libertarian. It is not to late to embrace freedom and to realize the individuals ability to care for themselves better than a stanger. And to realize the governments role in our lives should be a small role. Especially, in an age of technology that makes government control so easy.

The last time this country had peace, (unfortunately, before my time) the president was a career soldier. His parting words, in his farewell address, warned of a growing military industrial complex, being overseen by presidents with no military experience. Very prescient.

Pat, that hat looks very good on you. I hope you feel free to wear it whenever you want. You earned it.

Reply to mpc
mpc
11/12/09 - 00:02

Dear Reply:

You know that I do not agree with you, either, politically. I do respect you; you are a good writer. I look forward to your column , every Wednesday. That being said, I give you s***, because you deserve it.
Happy Veteran's Day.
M

repug
11/11/09 - 08:57

I can't believe that ole Pat would bring out that stupid looking hat once again on Veterans Day. Why doesn't he just wear a sandwich board saying, "Look at me. I'm a Korean War hero". Most heroes I know and I know a lot of them wouldn't be caught dead in such a hat with all their ribbons, etc.

By the way, Mountain Express publisher, why do you list Pat's column under "Other Views". In the same paper his byline is on the lead article. Seems to me he should be in "Our View".

Reply to repug
reply
11/11/09 - 15:54

Repug,
While I never agree with mpc's politics, his closing comments above show some class that you clearly lack.
That said, in what branch of the service and which war did you serve?

Leave a Comment





?   ?



Comments with contents that seek to incite or inflame may be removed.

Comments that are in ALL CAPS will be removed.

Comments that are off-topic or that include profanity or personal attacks, libelous or other inappropriate material will be removed from the site. Entries that are unsigned or contain signatures by someone other than the actual author will be removed. We will take steps to block users who violate any of our posting standards, terms of service or any other policies governing this site. Use of this system denotes full acceptance of these conditions. Please review the full rules governing commentaries and discussions. You are fully responsible for the content that you post.

To report an inappropriate or offensive comment click here

 Local Weather 
Find on this site:

Other Sites

Follow IdahoMtnExpress on Twitter

Copyright © 2010 Express Publishing Inc. 
All Rights reserved. Reproduction in whole or in part in any form or medium without express written permission of Express Publishing Inc. is prohibited. 

The Idaho Mountain Express is distributed free to residents and guests throughout the Sun Valley, Idaho resort area community. Subscribers to the Idaho Mountain Express will read these stories and others in this week's issue.