

| TALK BACK: Now you can add YOUR comments about this article. |
print version
email
print version
email
There are 12 comments
The comments below are from the readers of mtexpress.com and in no way represent the views of Express Publishing Inc. 11/24/09 - 16:31
timber, this argument is flawed. plants do not have a central nervous system. nor do they have pain receptors or a brain. therfore, the are incapable of feeling pain. even if we were to disregard all the scientific data collected on the topic and pretend that plants do in fact feel pain and that you are generally concerned with the well being of plants, then you should go vegetarian. why? because it takes many many pounds of plant based food to produce a single pound of animal flesh. so if you wanted to minimalize plant suffering, you could do that by avoiding flesh all together and eating a plant based diet. 11/24/09 - 16:30
timber, this argument is flawed. plants do not have a central nervous system. nor do they have pain receptors or a brain. therfore, the are incapable of feeling pain. even if we were to disregard all the scientific data collected on the topic and pretend that plants do in fact feel pain and that you are generally concerned with the well being of plants, then you should go vegetarian. why? because it takes many many pounds of plant based food to produce a single pound of animal flesh. so if you wanted to minimalize plant suffering, you could do that by avoiding flesh all together and eating a plant based diet. 10/31/09 - 08:25
Hitler wanted everybody's name to.. 10/31/09 - 08:04
mpc - why is it that you can't use your real name, chicken I guess? And, you can't spell, either. 11/02/09 - 07:55
Dear Lynn: As I have written in these pages before, if something I have said is not true, just say so and I will apologize. I am just repeating a quote the newspaper attributed to you. According to the newspaper, you said you shot a bullet into the air to scare away a wolf. If you did not, have the newpaper issue a correction. Newspapers do that all the time when they make mistakes. And please accept my apology. If what I said is true, I am sure you will think twice before doing it again. That bullet could have hit a wolf, or a chicken. 10/30/09 - 23:11
At first my reaction was to be repulsed. As I read the article though my heart warmed. This is the type of program I wish we had around the nation. People are so disconnected with where our food comes from. There are people out there that really think our meats are produced in a factory and never came from an animal. Perhaps people would eat less meat if they knew the suffering of the animals. In the very least I'd hope that they'd buy their meat from humanly raised sources. I'm glad that the students aren't being forced to partake in the slaughter. 10/30/09 - 22:36
I can not believe that a school in Idaho would have to teach such a thing. Let me rephrase that; any school in Idaho but the Community school. 10/31/09 - 09:41
Community=Communism. 10/30/09 - 22:13
Kids - you can make a choice. You will survive without eating a chicken that you helped raise. Say no, take the chicken home, and let it live. I grew up on a ranch, never could accept that animals were only for the purpose of killing them for food. You can protest, don't buy into the ag industry that brings such agony to animals. 10/30/09 - 22:41
You would shoot a bullet into the air, without any regard to where it fell, but you would not kill a chicken. You go, Lynn. A simple question for a simple mind; if chickens were not raised for food, do you think they may be extinct? 11/01/09 - 15:21
Amen. I'm proud to be vegetarian. 11/02/09 - 15:37
Lynne do you own leather boots? I bet you do don't you? Probably don't eat fish either. Who's to say plants don't have feelings too? What does that leave to eat? Dirt? Rocks? Leave a Comment
1
|
|
Copyright ©
2010
Express Publishing Inc. The Idaho Mountain Express is distributed free to residents and guests throughout the Sun Valley, Idaho resort area community. Subscribers to the Idaho Mountain Express will read these stories and others in this week's issue. |